Case Studies:
Cerveceria Costa Rica (a subsidiary of Florida Ice&Farm) Cerveceria Costa Rica , a local brewery, and Heredia city water utility (ESPH) pay neighbouring landowners to manage their forests in accordance with the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification. The minimum area eligible is 2 ha, so in theory the scheme should benefit smallholders. In practice however, the main recipients of payments are it wealthy landowners with second homes in the area. The agreement is facilitated by the National Forestry Fund (FONAFIFO) and the local NGO FUNDECOR. Ongoing since 2001 (5-year agreement). Brewing company interested in protecting its water sources. FUNDECOR and FONAFIFO have also worked hard to set up a dialogue with the user (given that it is such a large one and pays very little for the water used: currently US$400/year). SupplyForest owners in the catchment area of Rio Segundo: contracts cover 1000ha. Their commitment is to protect their forest through a management plan that guarantees its permanence and prevents changes. DemandPrivate user.Cerveceria Costa Rica is a subsidiary of Florida Ice & Farm. The company produces beer, fruit juices, and bottled water and is the first manufacturing industry engaged in PES. As their area of interest within the watershed, overlaps with the ESPH, the two companies have joined forces to increase the level of the local payment. IntermediaryFONAFIFO, the Costa Rican National Forestry Fund is the main intermediary, at national level. The local forestry NGO FUNDECOR intermediates the deal at the local level. FUNDECOR contacts eligible landowners and offers technical assistance for the application process (including technical studies and legal paperwork). In this case, in addition to participation in the national PES programme, applicants through FUNDECOR also enter a certification scheme for forest management (Forest Stewardship Council (FSC). The contract commitments from the ESPH side in this agreement are subscribed by FUNDECOR. ServiceWater flow and water quality. CommodityConservation and Protection of existing ecosystems in forestland. Payment mechanismIntermediary-based transaction, through FONAFIFO (the national forestry fund) . La Florida agreed to cover the full amount of payments (at the time US$ 45/ha/yr) to 1,000 ha of forest in the upper part of the Rio Segundo Watershed. (The company also pays 1 colon (about US$0.002) per bottle of water sold, and an additional 1 colon per bottle recycled, to the National Park Foundation. ESPH contributes with US$ 22/ha/yr raising the payments to a total of US$67/ha/year. Terms of paymentOne-off cash payment from the companies to FONAFIFO, who then distributes payments on an annual basis to landowners for the duration of the contracts, via FUNDECOR. Funds involvedESPH contributes with total US$ 22,000 per year (US$ 110,000 over five years) and La Florida with US$ 45, 000 per year, including a fee for FONAFIFO administration costs coming to a total of 273,000 over five years.Analysis of costs and benefits EconomicIntermediation costs. Users : Both La Florida and ESPH contribute to FONAFIFO administration costs with US$ 4/ha/yr. Providers: FUNDECOR charges 12% of the total amount of the contract as intermediation fee charged only if the application is successful. EnvironmentalThe initiative helps to protect important water recharge areas in the upper watersheds of the country. This provides benefits for biodiversity and landscape beauty. It is unclear whether these areas are under direct threat of conversion and whether there is significant additionality. SocialThe area is rather wealthy and there are no direct impacts on the poor. Minimum area is 2 ha, so in theory it should benefit smallholders, but it is more likely to benefit wealthy landowners with second homes in the area.The company pays very little for the water extraction rights (Canon de Agua). Some people argue that it is only fair that they should pay additional money for the environmental service but even that is not enough. This situation will change with the application of the new Water Fees law (Canon del Agua), approved in 2006. However, investments from companies like Florida ICE&FARM in PES will be recognised when they have to pay the new fees. FUNDECOR deals with monitoring through Geographical Information Systems (GIS) and field visits. One-to-one negotiations with the company are lengthy and expensive. However, these types of negotiations have contributed to capacity building in FONAFIFO and helped them design the stream-lined certificates (CES) to deal with private firms (see CES in this review). This case presents an example of how to increase the attractiveness of the scheme, by pooling contributions from different users to increase the payment level in a priority area. The owners of FLORIDA ICE AND FARM are also the main investors in the Melia Hotel, which is now paying for watershed services in Guanacaste (see case in this review). The company also pays 1 colon (about US$0.002 per bottle of water sold, and an additional 1 colon per bottle recycled, to the National Park Foundation.Florida contact: mailto:infor@florida.co.cr FONAFIFO (2005) The environmental Services Program: A success story of sustainable development implementation in Costa Rica. FONAFIFO Over a decade of action. Edited by Rodríguez, J.M.Costa Rica National Forestry Fund (FONAFIFO). San José Miranda, M. I. T. Porras and M. L. Moreno. 2003. The social impacts of payments for environmental services in Costa Rica. A quantitative field survey and analysis of the Virilla watershed. Markets for Environmental Services (MES) Series, number 1. London, International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED). http://www.iied.org/pubs/pdf/full/9245IIED.pdf
Ortiz, E. M. 2003. Costa Rica: Una Experiencia de Manejo Ambiental Inovadora-Sistema de Cobro y Pago por Servicios Ambientales en Costa Rica: Visión General. Programa de las Naciones Unidas para el Desarrollo PNUD and Escuela de Ingeniería Forestal. Instituto Tecnológico de Costa Rica. Feria de Soluciones Ambientales: Experiencia de Costa Rica. http://www.undp.org/surf-panama/docs/bcpr/soluciones_ambientales_servicios_ambientales.pdf Rojas, M. and Aylward, B. 2003. What are we learning from experiences with markets for environmental services in Costa Rica? _ A review and critique of the literature. Markets for Environmental Services (MES) Series, number 2. International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) http://www.iied.org/eep/pubs/documents/MES2.pdf . Information on FUNDECOR website: http://www.fundecor.org/transferencia/proyectos_es.shtmlhttp://www.fonafifo.com/paginas_espanol/proyectos/e_pr_convenios.htm |
 |
|